After Jalen Harvey scored in the 87th minute to tie Green Bay 3-3 on Monday, Anthony Hunter scored the game-winner in the 93rd minute for a 4-3 overtime victory before a disbelieving partisan Santaga Stadium crowd.
The first time the Blue Demons fell behind in their season opener Friday night, they responded in rapid fashion. But the second time, they couldn't find the equalizer.
DePaul can hardly wait to kick off the 2014 men's soccer season that begins with a 7 p.m. match Friday at NCAA tournament qualifier Milwaukee.
Four DePaul rookies led the Blue Demons to a 2-0 victory over Lewis on Saturday in the final exhibition match of the preseason.
For starters, this was something to build upon as DePaul did a nice job of defending on Tuesday but just couldn't find the back of the net.
The Hoyas and Golden Eagles shared the BIG EAST regular-season crown a season ago and appear in the NSCAA Continental Tire Preseason Top 25.